Tuesday, February 7, 2012

Robert E. Lee's "Country"



Greetings Cosmic Americans!

I have been been dutifully at my post scouring Youtube for interesting videos worthy of sharing here. I came across this one portraying a Robert E. Lee reenactor giving his take on allegiance to his "country" of Virginia and how the founders formed a union of "countries" under the Constitution.

I will have to give props to the reenactor - he has the look down. But his understanding of the formation of a union of sovereign countries seems a little more than problematic. Like Lincoln, many other folks understood that the formation of a union of former colonies made one country of constituent parts - and thus the formation of the Union created states...bound by allegiance to an indissoluble nation. What do you think?

Peace,

Keith

4 comments:

  1. Scott A. MacKenzieFebruary 7, 2012 at 7:24 AM

    I loved the European union comparison. Yikes, it shows how desperate they are to legitimate secession. Anything to evade the real cause: the protection of slavery.

    ReplyDelete
  2. They also neglect the obvious problem of states created out of land purchased or conquered by the United States after 1787. Arkansas was clearly not a "country" when it became part of the U.S. Nor was it a "country" when it was admitted as a state. The federal government purchased the land that became Arkansas using common funds from all parts of the Union.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for pointing that out Pat - so this mean that only four Confederate states were part of the original 13 "countries" - Georgia, North and South Carolina, and Virginia.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Do you drink a lot of coffee?

    ReplyDelete